NetWellness is a global, community service providing quality, unbiased health information from our partner university faculty. NetWellness is commercial-free and does not accept advertising.
Tuesday, January 27, 2015
In 1947, the Nuremberg Court found sixteen doctors guilty of crimes against humanity for experimenting on concentration camp prisoners. The court released the Nuremberg Code that outlined 10 points to help make sure that research on human subjects was ethical. Since the Nuremberg Code, there have been many changes in how research is carried out and what we do to protect research participants.
In the USA, scientists and the research community did not always protect the people who were involved in research studies, and there was no one to look out for research participants' rights. As a result, in 1974, the government passed a law to create the National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research. This group created the Belmont Report, which defines three (3) principles that should guide research involving human subjects: 1) respect for persons, 2) beneficence, and 3) justice. In 1981, the government used these principles to create regulations to protect human subjects and make sure that research studies were reviewed.
If a researcher has an idea for a research study, s/he will create a very detailed plan that explains the project. The researcher then gives this research plan to a group of people called an Institutional Review Board (IRB). The IRB reads over the research plan to make sure that it asks a good question and that the volunteers will be as safe as possible. If the IRB thinks that the research is good, it will approve it.
The IRB will also review the research study at least once a year to make sure that everything is going well. If a research participant has a complaint or a question, the participant should contact the IRB.
I stands for INSTITUTIONAL, meaning that the study must follow the hospital, university or institution rules that apply to wherever the research will be done.
R is for REVIEW, meaning the study is checked closely to see that rules are followed.
B stands for BOARD. This means a group of professionals and community members look at the research study.
When the IRB reviews a study plan that people are a part of, they:
In reviewing research plans, the IRB makes sure that researchers follow these basic ethical principles:
Equal benefits and equal burdens -- the idea behind the principle of justice is to make sure that no one is being taken advantage of or doing more than their fair share. We have to be careful not to burden specific groups just because they may not or cannot say "no." Certain groups may be more likely to be taken advantage of in a research setting. These people may be less able to defend themselves than other persons. These groups include:
The IRB has extra ways to protect and keep these groups safe. The IRB does this when they review research that has these special groups taking part.
Researchers must show that their study plan follows the correct informed consent process. Informed consent tells you your rights as a person taking part and what you are being asked to do. This must be clear and easy to understand. It includes
Voluntarily taking part in a study is a vital part of informed consent. It is okay for people taking part to be allowed to stop taking part at any time, and there will be nothing negative happen to you if decide to stop. Researchers must also show how they will protect your privacy and confidentiality. They must tell the IRB what they will do with the information they collect and how others will not be able to see what you have shared without your saying it is okay.
Beneficence means trying to make good things happen and making sure means that the risk of harm or injury for people who take part is kept as low as possible. A risk is minimal when the chance of harm is no more than what might happen in daily life or during a routine exam.
The IRB also ensures that the potential for benefit has been maximized. Some benefits directly help the people who take part, such as taking a medicine as a research that helps the person's medical condition. Benefits include adding to new knowledge that will help others.
This article is a NetWellness exclusive.
Last Reviewed: May 15, 2011
Nicole M Deming, JD, MA
Assistant Professor of Bioethics
School of Medicine
Case Western Reserve University